Pocketful of Pinecones by Karen Andreola: A nature notebook guide
I want to be just like Carol. Lessons from a 1930’s homemaker and homeschool mother on nature notebooking.
Links included may be paid links. My family may receive a small commission if you make a purchase. Thank you for your support! For more information, see our terms, privacy policy, and disclaimer. All opinions are my own and I was not paid for this review.
A Homeschool Mother’s Treasure
If you’ve been around here for a while, you know I’m a huge fan of Karen Andreola. I consider her not just an author, but a friend and a Titus 2 woman in my life. Those women are rare but oh, so special. Her books and emails have ministered to me all throughout the summer.
Pocketful of Pinecones is actually my fifth Karen Andreola book. I’ve also read Michael’s Gentle Wife, Story Starters, Mother Culture, and A Charlotte Mason Companion. Every single one has left its mark on me, but this one is special.
I highly recommend any and all of Karen’s books.
Karen’s books have a way of reaching deep into your soul, and her character, Carol, feels like an old friend. Carol has walked alongside me through the pages of these novels, shaping the way I think about education, home life, and my calling as a mother.
If you’re looking to add a book to your Mother Culture, a book to read with your cup of tea or coffee, or if you love historical fiction, this is a great book to pick up!
The Story of Carol and the Weavers
Pocketful of Pinecones begins the story of the Weaver family: Carol, her husband Michael, their children Don and Emily, and a new baby on the way. Set in the 1930’s, Carol is brand new to homeschooling. Through her eyes, we watch a mother find her footing—hesitant at first, but passionate about her children, committed to making it work, and celebrating the little victories along the way.
Carol’s journey continues in the other two books in the trilogy, Lessons from Blackberry Inn and Michael’s Gentle Wife. But this first installment is where we see her make the life-changing decision to homeschool and begin implementing Charlotte Mason’s methods in her home.
You can see my review of the third book in the series in my Youtube video above. This book radically changed my homeschool, and my heart. It feels like the first year of homeschooling all over again!
A Story + Nature Notebook Guide
Here’s what makes Pocketful of Pinecones so special: it’s not just a sweet historical fiction story about a homeschooling family. It’s also a how-to guide—specifically, an introduction to nature notebooking for mothers.
Each chapter is written as one of Carol’s journal entries. At the end of every chapter, there’s a list of nature elements mentioned—complete with their Latin names. Poems and hymns are sprinkled throughout the story like little treasures.
Reading it, I felt like a student in Carol’s homeschool. I got to go on nature walks with her family, explore their backyard, and stroll the countryside as they discovered birds, wildflowers, insects, and even tiny critters that might be overlooked in a busier pace of life.
She shows us how a backyard can be turned into a science and art lesson in just a few moments. I loved how sweet and simple she made this process for the ordinary moms like me. I don’t have a big area of land to work with, but I have a backyard just like Carol and her family.
Thankfully, I also live right on the edge of the woods, so there are many creatures and plants to explore on our little half an acre.
Nature Notebooking Comes Alive
Before reading this book, I’ll admit—I was overthinking nature notebooking. I loved the idea, but it felt complicated and I wasn’t sure if I had the space to do it with just a backyard. Carol’s simple, joyful approach changed that for me.
Click the image for the Handbook of Nature Study Link!
In the story, Don and Emily make their own nature notebooks from scratch. They sketch, write, and collect observations. Her son Don was very apprehensive at first, because he was insecure about his drawing abilities. My son is that way, too. He’s starting out a bit shaky because he feels that he can’t draw well, and he tends to like everything to be a bit perfect. Carol has a sweet way of helping him along, and I’ve taken her words to heart. I’m hoping I’ll be able to help my son along the way she did with hers.
What strikes me most is how Carol turns the simplest moments outside into meaningful science lessons. By using her field guide, she and her children learn all about different plants, animals, and insects living all around them throughout the year. They see these things change with the seasons, and record those changes.
I even bought the Handbook of Nature Study that Carol uses in the novel. It’s still in print today, and other resources she mentions are still available as well. Some are listed in the back of the book for your reference.
By the time I finished reading, I had already decided—my son will be making his own nature notebook this year, and I think I’ll start one for myself as well.
Why It’s for Every Mom
You don’t have to be a Charlotte Mason homeschooler to enjoy Pocketful of Pinecones. You don’t even have to be interested in nature notebooking. This book stands on its own as a cozy, uplifting story of faith, family, and learning together.
Carol’s devotion to her husband, children, and the Lord shines through every page. Her gentle, steady walk with God is woven into her journal entries without feeling forced—it’s simply part of who she is.
This is what I would call a true Christian book. Not Christian-lite, like so many Christian books today. But a book for the Christian mom who needs ministering to. Above all, that’s why I love Karen Andreola’s books. Her devotion to The Lord and spreading the Gospel of Jesus Christ through her writing is tangible. You see the love she has for the Lord on every page.
The chapters are short, making it an ideal read for a few stolen minutes of quiet or as part of your own “Mother Culture” time.
Don’t Skip the Appendices
One of my favorite parts of the book is the appendices. Don’t skip them! Karen includes wonderful book lists and a heartfelt afterword where she shares about her own family and the inspiration behind one of my favorite characters, Emma Cook.
And here’s a fun fact: Karen wrote Pocketful of Pinecones before the internet was a daily companion. She writes, “Like Carol did, I observed this same nature first-hand myself (and with my children) while leafing through a field guide.”
The story begins in September—the start of a school year—and follows the Weavers through all four seasons. More than 200 different nature elements are observed and recorded throughout the book. Birds, butterflies, insects, wildflowers, and so much more fill the pages.
It’s a perfect example of how nature study isn’t something you “add on” to your homeschool—it’s a way of seeing the world together.
My Mother Culture Takeaway
While talking with Karen, she shared an idea that’s shaping my own Mother Culture practice: keep a nature notebook for yourself. Not with the pressure to fill it in a set time frame or keep it perfectly organized—just make entries whenever something catches your eye.
It might be a flower blooming on your walk, a bird at your feeder, or a pretty leaf on the sidewalk. This slower, more leisurely approach is perfect for busy moms. And the beauty is, you can begin any time—no need to wait for January or a new school year.
Refreshed for the New School Year
After finishing Pocketful of Pinecones, I felt refreshed, inspired, and eager to start the new school year. Nature notebooking went from something I was overcomplicating to something simple and joyful. I’m convinced that if you read this book, you’ll feel the same.
It’s not just about recording what you see—it’s about cultivating eyes to notice beauty, hearts to appreciate it, and hands willing to preserve it on paper.
Where to Go Next
Once you’ve read Pocketful of Pinecones, you can continue the
Weaver family’s story in Lessons from Blackberry Inn and Michael’s Gentle Wife. I plan to start Blackberry Inn next, and I have a feeling it’s going to be just as rich and inspiring.
If you’re looking for encouragement, practical ideas, and a story that will make you fall in love with the art of learning all over again, this is the book to read.
And if you do decide to start your own nature notebook—whether for your children or yourself—I’d love to hear about it. Who knows? Maybe one day your entries will inspire another homeschool mom, just like Carol’s have inspired me.
Have you read Pocketful of Pinecones? If so, what was your favorite takeaway? And if not, is it going on your reading list now?
